Return to Classical Contents Page Find Old Articles Contact Writers Go to Inkpot.com

Issue 56
This article was last updated on
21 February, 2001

More Stuff:




To Bach Is To Be Human
A Tribute to the Master

A SELECTION OF REVIEWS:

  • Brandenburg Concerti
  • The Orchestral Suites
  • The Harpsichord Concerti
  • Solo Harpsichord Concerti (Levin/Hänssler)
  • Violin & Oboe Concerti
  • Oboe Concerti

  • Cello Suites (Wispelwey)
  • Cello Suites (Yo-Yo Ma)
  • Partitas & Sonatas for Solo Violin (Mela)
  • Partitas & Sonatas for Solo Violin (Podger)
  • Violin Sonatas (Complete) Podger/Pinnock (Channel).

  • Bach Transcribed for Piano (Lauriala)
  • Harpsichord Music by the Young Bach (Hill)
  • Anna Magdelena Notebook 1725. Behringer (Hänssler)
  • Klavierbüchlein for Wilhelm Friedemann Bach. Payne (Hänssler).
  • The Six Partitas (Leonhardt)
  • The Goldberg Variations
  • The Six Partitas (Leonhardt)
  • The Art of Fugue (ALSQ)

  • The Sacred Masterworks (Decca)
  • Sacred Music in Latin (Hänssler)
  • The Motets
  • The Magnificat
  • Mass in B minor
  • St. Matthew Passion
    (Klemperer/Veldhoven)
  • St. Matthew Passion (Gardiner/DG)

    For even more Bach reviews, check out the Inkvault!

  • Johann Sebastian BACH (1685-1750)

    The Motets, BWVs 225-230


    Kammerchor der Augsburger Domsingknaben
    conducted by Reinhard Kammler

     

    DEUTSCHE HARMONIA MUNDI Baroque Esprit
    (BMG Classics) 05472-77436-2

    [60:18] budget-price

    WARNING: No libretto provided.

     
    by Ng Yeuk Fan

    Johann Sebastian Bach This may be a budget recording compared to all the others in full and mid-price. However, this recording is certainly no push over. It boasts good quality sound and admirable acoustics and as an alternative to the other versions which replaces trebles with sopranos, this authentic treble version is a welcome change. Other versions utilizing trebles include an early 1960s Tölzer Boys Choir recording on a Philips label which has not been released on CD and is no longer available. Fortunately, I still have a cassette recording of it.

    Admittedly, trebles in general do not deliver their lines with the same flair that accomplished sopranos are quite capable of. In addition, they are often accused of being uninvolved with the music emotionally. Nevertheless, trebles in an established boys' choir are often better trained and technically more competent than many sopranos in adult choirs. Trebles undergo stringent training programs and the few treble choirs that are world famous have every reason to be where they are - among the best.

    The Kammerchor der Augsburger Domsingknaben trebles are natural and they deliver their crystal-clear voices with first class control, tossing high notes off with finesse and ease not apparent amongst sopranos in a lesser class. Choral singing is also achieved with clean and clear lines, harmony is tight and full. Intonation flaws are few and far between.

    Detail from 'The Nativity' by Stefan Lochner (c.1410-1451) There are quite a few moments where one wishes for greater precision of execution. The direction of these boys seem to lack insight for there are parts when one feels that these masterpieces are treated as mere vocal exercises. Yet, the many moments of tight control and great understanding of the Bachian line proves to me beyond a doubt that my feelings are unfounded. This is a recording as worthy of a listen as any others that I have reviewed so far.

    Right: Detail from "The Nativity"
    by Stefan Lochner (c.1410-1451)

    In addition, there is a certain quality in these treble voices that strike me deep down. They sing fearlessly. The great difficulties are conquered without any signal of internal struggle, nor of strain or tiredness, and certainly without any fear. The treble voice boasts of these qualities not found in the adult voice. Though the reason for using boys instead of women may have been a social one, Bach must have understood this quality of the treble voice. Bach writes for the voice as if it was an instrument with inexhaustible breath and dexterity. Surely, he meant them to be sung by angels.

    Knowing this, the small imperfections are readily forgiven and the spirit of the music - in their original intentions, come to life in this recording.

    T h e · B a c h · M o t e t s
    Inktroduction & Review Index

    NG YEUK FAN is jealous of all these treble boys...

    If you wish to Add a Comment to this article, please email your comments to classical@inkpot.com.

    Return to Index Return to the Classical Index!...
    or Visit the Inkvault archives!
    220: 28.6.1998 © NG Yeuk Fan

    All original texts are copyrighted. Please seek permission from the Classical Editor
    if you wish to reproduce/quote Inkpot material.

    [an error occurred while processing this directive]