BRT
Philharmonic Orchestra, Brussels
Alexander Rahbari, Conductor
by
James Wegg
Writing a symphony is no
laughing matter.
Johannes Brahms
Brahms seems too willing to sacrifice sensuous beauty to the
cultivation of greatness and seriousness, severity and
complexity.
Eduard Hanslick, music critic writing after the
world première of Brahms’ First Symphony
Brahms
(right) was 43 and Alexander Rahbari 41 when they – nearly a
century apart – accepted the responsibility of, respectively,
completing a nearly 15 year gestation and giving a
deservedly-revered composition another life.
For the composer it was
a long struggle, filled with numerous re-writes, advice from
colleagues and the hidden fear of being unworthy of Schumann’s
daunting advance notice. The invisible master peered over
Brahms’ shoulder, raising his level of “acceptable,” yet,
finally, resulting in a masterwork truly worthy of the
designation. For the conductor, the impatience Brahms must have
felt carrying around such an incredibly important contribution
to music for all those years permeates this account.
The disc also features
the Variations on a Theme by Haydn, which pre-dates the
symphony and were most certainly another step along Brahms’
learning curve towards mastering the complexities of
orchestration. Positioning them after the symphony does neither
work any favours. The five bar theme intrigued the studied
creator who followed his own advice by “grounding” the work in
the bass line of the Passacaglia where the entirely
unexpected appearance of the triangle, even as the music draws
into itself – like telling a secret – never fails to astonish.
Sadly, Rahbari and his
overly reverberant band seem content to work their way through
these jewels rather than plumbing their depths.
The symphony fares
best. The booming introduction (espressivo e legato) is
too loud by half, making the appearance of the later fortissimos
non events. Once in the Allegro, the drive is present
but direction is lacking – no tears shed for ignoring the
exposition repeat. And Rahbari falls into the trap of slowing
the pulse when Brahms already beat him to it by lengthening the
notes then relaxing their rhythm so that the Meno Allegro
just starts, rather than emerges.
The Andante
sostenuto begins well and the BRT Philharmonic Orchestra’s
Principal Oboe - as is the case throughout - acquits himself
with distinction and greater focus of tone than the
concertmaster. Later, ensemble problems surface, confirming
that the few lapses in the first movement (notably the alignment
of the low strings with the contra bassoon) were not anomalies.
The Allegretto
is, in many ways, the finest outing of the recording, with
beautiful phrasing from the solo clarinet and an unhurried ease
in and out of the duple/triple alternations, but, just ahead of
the foreshadowing pizzicati, there’s a last-minute race that
mars the drama before it unfolds.
The magnificent
Finale is notable for its balance: strings/winds;
legato/staccato and compelling warmth in the chorale. Next time
Rahbari may realize that there is more to the famous tune than,
well, the melody and invite the violas to press their bows more
firmly into the rich harmony that draws our hearts as well as
our minds into the frame. When the coda arrives it truly snaps,
crackles and pops, but only to have the emergency brake
needlessly applied against Brahms’ already well-calculated
pedal.
Similarly, throughout
the Variations, the result could only improve if the
podium let the music play rather than force its content out of
the bars. A stodgy opening, much unwanted affectation and the
preponderance of vertical rather than horizontal thinking
combine to give this reading the more the feel of a
work-in-progress rather than a distinctive statement.
Nonetheless, for the
captivating feeling of an “artist in a hurry” that permeates
these performances, the disc is worth adding to a serious
collection. No doubt Brahms, too, had days like that. And what
a fascinating comparison it will be to make when Rahbari’s next
chance comes along to share his further experience and learning
from the privilege of working with some of the finest music ever
penned.
Readers' Comments
From: nike dunk (wcp2209@yahoo.cn / Wednesday, October 6, 2010 at 10:20:02)
Wow,It is the first physiological footwear.MBT shoes has a positive effect on the whole body.In stock. No tax .Shop the entire collection of Authentic MBT shoes.Free shipping to all over the US/UK,15 days money back policy.mbt shoes,High Quality,But Cheap Pice!Save Up to 60%.the Official US Website of mbt shoes,the Anti-Shoe.
Best Places to Buy Online! I've had a lot of shoes in my time, but I can honestly say mbt shoes are the first that have come with an instruction manual. What's to know about that ?MBT shoes By Swiss Masai. The reliable qualtiy as well as the competitive price.I will go to order more MBT.
From: mbt shoes (sasasa@gmail.com / Monday, November 29, 2010 at 09:55:06)
mbt shoes is the mbt masai shoes-the physiological mbt footwear.MBT Shoes can make you enjoy a unique mbt chapa experience of walking .
People http://www.sneaker-maniac.com always cheap Jordan sneaker marvel at the superb Michael Jordan's performance on the court cheap nike dunks free shipping for basketball, the Jordan is an independent gene, he alone determines that the movement of some of the attributes. But when you wholesale dunks want to revisit this history at the right time, you can choose to text, image or video data, and, Jordan shoes. Jordan cheap women shox r4 has repeatedly said: "part of the dress shoes that I was part of my personality." We can http://www.sneaker-maniac.com use the "Michael Jordan • • shoes" to refer to Michael Jordan, or call his shoes, and sometimes it is simply one of the two The. "Year after year, Jordan shoes, constantly changing, http://www.sneaker-maniac.com but all had the shoes on my behalf." Jordan said. At that time the media published a surprising news: Nike will be 1.25 million U.S. dollars, to purchase a rookie NBA 5 years of "the right shoes." Nike chose to "air" for the Jordan line of shoes named.
From: qwea (zero@yahoo.com / Monday, December 6, 2010 at 14:08:54)
Each source by dollar items the reporter from Shanghai Sheng CaoYesterday wholesale (November 24), United Overseas construction yiwu agent hit a record low share shoes wholesale prices once again. If you can not meet yiwu china the normal standards of build backdoor listing of yiwu UOB's joint tour Tang Jun's network may be facing in a yiwu market month after the delisting risk.Yesterday, yiwu fair the Joint Travel promotional products Network backdoor UOB building agent in yiwu listed companies fell 11% in heavy china wholesale volume, the lowest intraday yiwu wholesale fell to $ 0.62 per share
From: replica watches (sdfrsef@gmail.com / Tuesday, December 14, 2010 at 13:26:22)
President to Tout His
platinum iwc big pilot watch His PlanBy HUMA KHANDec. 10, 2010— President エルメス ブレスレット シルパー President Obama today
brought out former president replicas watches president and Democratic heavyweight Bill Clinton for swiss replica watch for an impromptu press conference to tout rolex oyster perpetual datejust ladies watch tout his tax
cut deal with Republicans エルメス ブレスレット Republicans that has earned the ire of replicas watches of many liberal Democrats.The agreement, taken as
replica iwc watches as a whole,
Clinton said, is, I rolex daytona replicas I believe, the best bipartisan agreement we dior watches replica we can reach to help the largest omega constellation double eagle watch largest number of
Americans, and to maximize replica iwc watches maximize the chances that the economic recovery
there are many online stores havingChristian Louboutin discount , i believe you gonna like it! yesterday, my friend bought aYves saint laurent shoes which is so beautiful, i am surprised by the design and style.
yesterday, my friend bought a cheap Ysl pumps which is so beautiful, i am surprised by the design and style. do you have a pair of Ysl sandals now? if not, go to online store and have one, it is so amazing!!!there are many online stores having Christian Louboutin pumps on sale, i believe you gonna like it!
Our company is specially in design,develop and produce the die casting parts of Aluminum,Znic,Brass and other meatals for light. We had start develop,design,and produce die-casting houseing of the led light 6 years before .
From: fgdfh (gffdg@gmail.com / Thursday, May 5, 2011 at 14:18:50)
Katie Couric's Nike Air Max 24 7negotiations withAir Max 24 7 Shoes CBS to stay at Jordan High Heelsthe network to doAir Jordan Heels a syndicated talk showJordan Heels are officially dead Nike Air Yeezy-- not gonna happen ... Cheap Air Yeezythis according to pluggedAir Max 24 7-in sources at CBS.Our sources say the breakdown occurred because CBS was unwilling toJordan Heels For Women give Katie substantial involvement in the network's news operation. We're told Air Jordan HeelsCBS honchos were willing to give Katie pieces for "60 Minutes," but nothing more --Nike Dunk High Heels and Katie wasn't having it.As a result, Katie will make a clean break from CBS and will not be doing a syndicated show for the network.
From: buy soccer shoes (360@gmail.com / Saturday, May 7, 2011 at 14:24:53)
Academy of Matrimonial Lawyers reported a decrease in divorce filings. filings.
to re-launch, and now,Ed Hardy Bikini to let you know what I GuiI have a pulse transmission thousand odd array! you enjoy the MBT Shoes Clearance art of Qi Men Dun Jia trapped people, trapped in today let you taste the taste ... ... "VIII Weiwei China, Huang Huang heavenly visitors beyond the Great Wall of Chapter XV Ed Hardy Swimwear ------------------------ "You broke my matrix method has been to, I do not what the point of peach Lin Lijia, the tactical deployment of re-mobilized. Now, to let you know my heritage Gui a pulse array of odd to me! You like to Churchthe art storm door Fighvibram five fingers clearance ters who were trapped today let you taste the taste ... ... Hidden in the woods old manmbt chapa known each other's plan.Host matrix method of their anti-trapped in the array.By now, with no regret.A pedestrian is about to rescue the emperor to leave.Leaders have been personally arranged down the impossible task. Already doomed to defeat.The heart of the forest a hidden gains and losses to the old man, but rather settle down, Huinu waning, stopped.Sitting cross-legged on the floor.Binocular micro mbt m.walkwhole family.Gros Ed Hardy Bikini or Ed Hardy Swimwearlymbt tunisha nose.Nose view of the heart, breath-hold your breath.Jmbt kisumuerneh Jinglv.He sought fame or fortune, self-MBT Salecultivation far more than ordinary effort, an instant heart no hi no anger.Lingtai a clear and bright, and he open the eyes.Peach quietly observed.Think Rune of the law.Array of people into a very sensitive impatient.Magic
MBT Shoes Clearance mbt MBT Discount or mbt shoes o r MBT Shoes Sale or MBT Sale or MBT Discount or mbt footwear or MBT sandals
Onitsuka Tiger OR asics onitsuka tiger OR onitsuka OR onitsuka tiger sale OR onitsuka tiger outlet OR onitsuka tiger running
onitsuka tiger mexico 66asics onitsuka tiger mexico 66asics mexico 66asics tiger minionitsuka tiger mini cooperASICS GEL 2ASICS GEL 2.1Onitsuka Tiger Mexico 66 DeluxeOnitsuka Tiger Tokidoki Mex loonitsuka tiger ultimate 81
From: ed hardy shirts (adsfasf@yahoo.com / Saturday, May 14, 2011 at 09:40:43)
shaking violently shaking coach outlet mall the lamp goes out, the two students over the body cold, shivering in shock Lingling, if it was going to move it.Mengjue a forceful storm hit Italy, two have not any idea.It thump thump twice.Like the body fell to the ground.Fainted. Room quieted down again, could be coach handbags saleheard off the needle.So dark, pitch dark. Mongolia gray shadows flashing palm room to see a short black figure out of thin air in iron pet before, like Guikui, strange inexplicable. This figure hunched stature, hand column crutches, the furniture,coach handbags clearance the whole body from head to toe cloak hidden in the dark canopy, the bowed head, training people see his face, only a see-phase two brown skinny like a skeletonhands, the hands of rushing to a painting full of strange runes bell.Khitan people to shaman shocking bigcoach handbags on sale wizard. Great Wizard of the cage in the Western beauty gaze a moment, diffuse sound warble: "Feier Na ... ... ... ... listen to the master Fei Erna phase call, wake up, wake up ... ..." extremely hoarse voice hoarse, but there is a partial insanity Healthaudience'sdiscount coach bags magic.Side said.Side of the wrist and gently shake the hands of jingling bells ringing, clear and melodious.Coincident with a curious rhythm, echoing in the air drifted between the misty land. Western cage trembling fingers about Sleeping Beauty, followed, acoach purses on sale ctually open the Meimou slowly, recovery over. Western beautiful sea-blue eyes were, like most magnificent sapphire.However, no species of heads, and looked stagnation seems to be no soul left the body an empty shell.
coach outlet mall or coach handbags sale or coach handbags clearance or coach handbags on sale or discount coach bags or mbt walking shoes o r coach purses on sale
From: DC Shoes Hats Wholesale (dufhdf@hotmail.com / Friday, June 10, 2011 at 11:38:36)
From: kllkk (229000098@qq.com / Wednesday, June 15, 2011 at 11:07:30)
Where can you buy the products of New Gucci?The answer is ourGucci Outlet. When you enter our Gucci Onlinestore home page you will find a number of Gucci 2011 products with superior quality in front of you. It contains the Gucci Shoes and Gucci Bagswhich are always designed with high qaulity and also follow the fashion trend. We are a famous Gucci Outlett with credit that we can assure you that all our products are in real quality. Recently, we have made a discounting activity. In there you can use the least money to buy the top quality products. Waiting for you!
disagreeableness -- didn't work as well for women.Two factors factors chanel wallets factors probably contribute to this, he said.First, I think people
disagreeable behavior by men and women differently, Judge wrote in in
in an email to ABCNews.com. Disagreeable men are [seen as]
and good negotiators. Disagreeable women are seen as bit**es or or Chanel Necklaces or labeled in a similarly derogatory way. Think of Martha
and Hillary Clinton. Appropriate behavior is somewhat gendered.It's age old old
From: cheap jordan shoes (selljordan@gmail.com / Thursday, April 12, 2012 at 18:21:19)
were filed in a New York federal court Friday to to cheap jordans to rebut claims by the Saudi government in recent court
that the 9//11 Commission had exonerated it of any connection connection
determined to expose the truth, said Beverly Burnett of Minnesota,
of Thomas E. Burnett, Jr., who died on United flight flight cheap jordan shoes flight 93 when it crashed into a Pennsylvania field after
fought hijackers for control of the plane. The financiers and and cheap jordans and enablers of those who murdered our loved ones are
alive, well and capable of supporting terrorism. The trail back back cheap jordan shoes online back to them still points to Saudi Arabia.Saudi Arabia Not
of Role in 9/11Sen. Kerrey's affidavit said it was incorrect incorrect cheap jordan shoes incorrect for the Saudis to claim that the 9/11 Commission
exonerated them. Stated simply, the 9/11 Commission did not have have cheap jordan shoes have the time, opportunity or resources to pursue all potentially
evidence on that important question, and the American public deserves deserves
deserves a more comprehensive inquiry into the issue, wrote Kerrey.The
are part of a multibillion-dollar lawsuit that has been working working cheap jordan shoes for sale working its way through the federal courts since 2002. Though
U.S. Justice Department has joined the Saudis in trying to to cheap jordan shoes to have lawsuits against the Saudis thrown out of court,
appellate court said late last year that foreign nations were were cheap jordans were not immune to lawsuits under some terrorism claims, meaning
of the Saudi case may be reheard.Lawyers for the Saudis Saudis cheap jordans Saudis have moved to have the affidavits disallowed. They did
immediately respond to a request for comment from ABC News. News. cheap jordans News. The Saudi embassy also did not immediately respond to
request for comment. The Saudis have always denied any connection connection cheap jordan shoes for sale connection to the 9/11 attacks. Fifteen of the 19 hijackers
crashed planes into the World Trade Center, the Pentagon and and
All
original texts are copyrighted. Please seek permission from the
Classical Editor
if you wish to reproduce/quote Inkpot material.
More
in this issue
Charles
Koechlin Le docteur Fabricius Vers la Voûte étoilée (HAENSSLER)
Karol Szymanowski String Quartets, Stravinsky Concertino,
Three Pieces, Double Canon (NAXOS)
Giuseppe Verdi La Traviata in Russian - Shumskaya, Kozlovsky, Lisitsian, Orlov (GUILD)
Johannes Brahms Sonata for Two Pianos, Op 34b Felix MendelssohnPiano Trio No 1, Op 49
Martha Argerich and Lilya Zilberstein, piano Renaud Capucon, violin Gautier Capucon, cello (EMI)
Morton Feldman Violin and Orchestra
Coptic Light, Piano and Orchestra (COL LEGNO)
Brahms
(right) was 43 and Alexander Rahbari 41 when they – nearly a
century apart – accepted the responsibility of, respectively,
completing a nearly 15 year gestation and giving a
deservedly-revered composition another life.