Edward
ELGAR Violin Concerti in B minor ¶
Max BRUCH
Violin Concerto in G minor
London
Symphony Orchestra
Sir Edward Elgar ¶
Landon Ronald
NAXOS HISTORICAL
8.110902
Felix
Mendelssohn Violin Concerti in E minor ◊
Edouard Lalo
Symphonie Espagnole
Ernest Chausson
Poeme
Orchestre des Concerts Colonne ◊
Paris Symphony Orchestra
all George Enescu, conductor
NAXOS HISTORICAL
8.110967
Both
super-budget price
by
Derek Lim
The American violinist
Yehudi Menuhin's importance to the violin is not immediately obvious
- certainly he didn't have (by far) the most reliable technique, nor
was his tone anything like Elman's or Kreisler's. His repertoire was
small compared with Heifetz's and any number of the next generation
of young violinists - Michael Rabin, Ginette Neveu et al were more
interesting, more brilliant.
But to compare him with these other violinists would be to miss the
point of Menuhin - in much of what he played he came the closest of
all to approaching what made up the core of the music - his
performances and recordings of the Beethoven and Brahms concerti
delve deeper into the music than many of his colleagues. Later he
was to be remembered more for the formation of his school, his
humanitarian efforts, his difficulties in the late 1940s with the
violin as well as his "cross-over" attempts with Stefan Grapelli and
Ravi Shankar (long before the term had been coined). But always
there was the music.
These two releases by Naxos Historical show different aspects of
this great artist when he was a teenager. The earliest of these was
made when in 1931 (the Bruch) when he was 15. Much is said of how
mature Menuhin's playing was when he was young and this performance
(for it is nothing less than one, despite the early recording
conditions) shows just how, and why HMV had signed him up at such a
young age to record with them.
It is a
sensational performance - without ever sentimentalizing the music,
he revels in the interpretative opportunities of the concerto.
Later, he would record it in a famous version with Efrem Kurtz, but
technically and interpretatively this beats that recording
hands-down. His playing is remarkably free of artifice and is
touched with an innocence that was a feature of Menuhin's
performances, but at a level which he would never again capture.
Landon Ronald was the in-house accompanist at that time (he also
conducted for many other soloists) and his treatment of the
orchestral parts is sympathetic and not at all obstrusive. (Menuhin with Elgar, left)
A year later he would record the Elgar violin concerto with Edward
Elgar himself, and it has never sounded better on disc than in this
transfer by Mark Obert-Thorne. Years after the recording, one
marvels at the sympathy Menuhin had with Elgar's music - remember,
it had only been recorded once at that time, by Albert Sammons and
Henry Wood. Obviously London had made a big impression on the young
Menuhin - he was later to make it his home. The pairing of the young
Menuhin with the elderly Elgar was a gimmick, as the producer later
admitted, but it was a gamble that paid off handsomely. Menuhin is
completely at home with Elgar's sound-world and his performance
closely resembles Sammons', always molto expressivo and
heart-on-sleeve, except that Sammons' even faster tempi leave
Menuhin's already swift ones in the dust. To be sure, Menuhin is
even at his age not totally at home with the technicalities and he
sounds strained from time to time.
But the noble insights he has into the music - the slow movement and the
accompanied cadenza especially more than make up for this. Listen to
how he expertly brings out the themes in the cadenza, making it
sound like the dream, realizing Elgar's strange conception (a
cadenza never had such a pivotal role as in this concerto), making
the return of the orchestra sound like the awakening from a dream
that it is supposed to sound like. His playing is gutsy and full of
fire, yet introspection is available when appropriate, and above all
wonderfully flexible in a manner he would not repeat.
This disc brings two classics of the gramophone together and to miss
it would be criminal, especially when Naxos offers it at such a low
price.
The
second disc is worth investing in as well -- Menuhin is here a few
years older and his accompanist is his teacher George(s) Enescu. His
performance of the Mendelssohn here already shows an understanding
of the Weltschmerz that he would explore in the later recordings of
the concerto, but again with an innocence of youth. He may be
technically more secure here than in the later recording, especially
with Furtwangler, but in both this and the Lalo, the conductor's
accompaniment is a tad too polite and deferential - not enough
characterization of the music and too self-effacing, too low key.
Still, one can enjoy Menuhin's treatment of the violin part, like a
soprano voice, singing always and with his agogic tempo adjustments
that made his interpretations special. Perhaps he felt restricted by
the presence of Enescu, yet from time to time his forceful
personality imposes itself. His performance of the second movement
is notable for the assured use of portamento and glissandi, and
sings like no other.
(Menuhin with Enescu, above)
In the Lalo, Menuhin shows virtuosity while attempting to
characterize the music - the result is attractive and riveting,
within the confines of the rather limited sound quality here - this
music really needed modern sound for it to fully show off its
colours.
I would recommend the second disc to fans of Menuhin, as he bettered
himself in the Mendelssohn with Furtwangler, but will add that both
discs will help you better understand why he was so revered as a
child.
From: replica watches (sucy1317@gmail.com / Thursday, June 3, 2010 at 13:29:22)
LuoKeShi bag for a surprise, a very dramatic contrast with restoring ties, future, interwoven with watchessimple, the complex, full of halfback personality is very common talent. Voice: in the 1970s to the disco style hyperbole, chief director freda auspicious Annie design, anxious to completely from Tom ford's brilliant ring. Of course, not the spring and summer of sexy style or brand symbol of early 1960s, the watches saleappearance of inspiration, performance of the cold tonal arrangement of fashion, the silver metal filled with hexagon specular burnish, 07 'spring and summer gucci bright like a magic and excitement. Voice: in the 1970s to the disco style hyperbole.
From: Replica Watch (wwatches@ymail.com / Tuesday, June 22, 2010 at 09:13:14)
From: google (google@gmail.com / Tuesday, July 27, 2010 at 14:42:23)
Buy at lower prices replica hangbags and shoes and save up to 80-90%. Buy Handbag Louis Vuitton. We are a louis vuitton outlet store and offer cheap replica
Gillette holds strong as the ¡°best for men¡± for personal care, owning 70 percent ... The lv brand is also gathering strong momentum in China,
YouTube streaming video - Louis Vuitton Journeys: the greatest game - For the world cup 2010 lv outlet launch a special ad campaign with
Price:$200. Louis Vuitton Tambour elegants lv Here you can find such world top brands as Omega watches, Rolex watches,
From: shely (hxj@126.com / Tuesday, August 3, 2010 at 15:26:28)
From: Classic Short UGG boots (hotuggboots@gmail.com / Friday, August 20, 2010 at 10:56:12)
More and more people are looking for the simple,but fashion boots. Classic Short UGG boots | Classic Short UGG boots covered with high quality sheepskin will make your feet feel comfortable. Classic Tall Stripe Cable Knit UGG Boots | Classic Tall Stripe Cable Knit UGG Boots are made for fashion and comfortable which deeply allur many women's love. Scalloped UGG Moc | Scalloped UGG Moc is a cute little moccasin-style slip on but with different tread than the Classic Crochet UGG Boots | Classic Crochet UGG Boots,What’s more, these Classic argyle knit ugg boots | Classic argyle knit ugg boots are very perfect for those cold days in winter.and Seline UGG Boots | Seline UGG Boots are great to go through the security lines fast.The Classic UGG Boots | Classic UGG Boots combines a classic prep school pattern and cozy sweater knit for the coolest, comfiest, casual look.
From: Cheap Christian Louboutin Shoes (hotclshoes@gmail.com / Monday, August 30, 2010 at 15:07:52)
We have Cheap Christian Louboutin Shoes | Cheap Christian Louboutin Shoes with top quality for women show women's taste.A pair of Christian Louboutin Boots | Christian Louboutin Boots in your closet will help you to transform any outfit.Christian Louboutin thigh high boots | Christian Louboutin thigh high boots are going mainstream.Choose the height of the heels to suit your personal preference. And Christian Louboutin Tall Boots | Christian Louboutin Tall Boots are coupled with sound support to showcase their beautiful legs.Christian Louboutin not only provide a variety of pumps, sandals, but also Christian Louboutin Ankle Boots | Christian Louboutin Ankle Boots.With Christian Louboutin sandals | Christian Louboutin sandals,you'll be charming, sexy, and so sophisticated.It seems that people who always love to choose Christian Louboutin short boots | Christian Louboutin short boots.Never be surprised if someone tells you she got a pair of Christian Louboutin Pumps | Christian Louboutin Pumps proudly.However many forget that they have some interesting Christian louboutin men's shoes | Christian louboutin men's shoes designs up their sleeves.
From: Discount Christian Louboutin Shoes (sellclshoes@gmail.com / Friday, September 3, 2010 at 16:07:41)
Many women can not resist the beautiful Discount Christian Louboutin Shoes | Discount Christian Louboutin Shoes, when they soon fell in love with a pair of Christian Louboutin boots | Christian Louboutin boots, they would do everything possible to get them.This Autumn and Winter, Christian Louboutin short boots are still the theme of fashion.Christian Louboutin has turned quite some heads this season with his new Christian Louboutin men's shoes | Christian Louboutin men's shoes line. It seems that people who always love to choose Christian Louboutin short boots | Christian Louboutin short boots. Because they think that Christian Louboutin tall boots | Christian Louboutin tall boots are so feminine and the Christian Louboutin short boots have so great taste.If you are fond of Christian Louboutin Thigh High Boots | Christian Louboutin Thigh High Boots, you will also like the other two Christian Louboutin Ankle Boots | Christian Louboutin Ankle Boots We are eager to establish business relations with all of you.Christian Louboutin sandals | Christian Louboutin sandals are advised for women who crave for fashion. Whether you wish to acquisition trend shoes out for dating or leisure shoes for absorbing activities,Christian louboutin pumps | Christian louboutin pumps on auction can amuse you.
From: begina (canyou@gmail.com / Tuesday, September 14, 2010 at 11:44:23)
New black and white on red shoes christian louboutin shoes - Louboutin shoes christian louboutin shoes sale Shop the 2010 gucci Fall Winter Collection Online Today Looking for gucci bags gucci products 80% OFF Authentic gucci handbags Free Ship We Buy cartier watches Earn Top cartier Dollar for Your Watch Breitling breitling watches fashion breitling watch louis vuitton handbags denim leather bags, not price,LV monogram canvas bag, priced at 715 U.S. dollars lv of stylish lv handbags louis vuitton sale The new autumn wallet louis vuitton wallet elegant plain LV Omega (omega watches) List Constellation Series Automatic Mechanical Men
From: buy womens designer handabgs online (zdhkw2010@gmail.com / Tuesday, September 21, 2010 at 16:56:41)
Coogi jeans is the leader in luxury fashion best known for its signature material and unique design,which Combine with traditional and modern fashion ed hardy clothing elements, Coogi jeans give the jeans world a new refresh concept. Thousands of consumers in many countries have weared Cheap Coogi jeans. Lots of feedbacks from our clients show that they are satisfied with the best materials .Brand jeans Online have so many types that you can choose what you want.We are looking forward to building sincere and long-term business relationships with you
From: Balenciaga Handbags (parker.piao@gmail.com / Monday, September 27, 2010 at 14:34:20)
From: nike air max (sasd@gmail.com / Monday, October 4, 2010 at 10:45:06)
In the study, 26 young Nike Air Max men used joysticks to move a cursor while Nike Air Max 1they stared in another direction. Half of the twenty-somethings were experienced Nike Air Max 2010 video gamers — who had played at least four hours of video games per week for the last three Nike Air Max 2009years — and the other half were not. Both groups trained on the console until they were equally proficient in accuracy and movement time.
From: bracelet (3243224@qq.com / Monday, October 4, 2010 at 12:06:07)
From: Air Yeezys (anyonees@163.com / Tuesday, October 12, 2010 at 11:41:16)
Still, seniors Air Yeezys like McNeil said they'll be thinking about the issue when Cheap Air Yeezy they go to vote, and Nike Air Yeezy experts said the news comes at a bad time for Democrats Nike Air Max already facing Kanye West Louis Vuitton Sneakers potentially big losses in November. Seniors Louis Vuitton Sneakers are the most loyal of voters, and their support is Louis Vuitton Shoes especially important during midterm elections, when turnout is generally lower."If you're the ruling party, this is not the sort of thing you want to have happening two weeks before an election," said Andrew Biggs, a former deputy commissioner at the Social Security Administration and now a resident scholar at the American Enterprise Institute.
From: omega watches (guan41500@163.com / Saturday, October 16, 2010 at 13:58:04)
From: w2788695 (550717542@qq.com / Wednesday, October 20, 2010 at 09:41:45)
Unique shoes supra, is a favorite of many young stars, and I love it. Stylish and comfortable foot feeling so many young people crazy
for it.
Supra is the best-selling U.S. brand of shoes. Supra Vaider Shoes Although it is a new brand, but it grew into
one of the most successful brand of shoes, supra vaider will be the perfect luxury style combined with extreme
sports, a unique position to design and alternative fashion csdsupra1019, aesthetic csdmiaomiao03, fashion, the perfect combination of alternative and skateboards, has become
popular culture and even the United States shoes much sought after community of a new brand. Supra Suprano
Shoes, with many of the touted big-name riders, and doomed it to take the high road shoes, work very pleasant surprise, there is a taste of the influx of people must Oh! 8
supra shoes, not to be missed, Supra TK Society is definitely tide shoes, including the supra-footwear-tuf-muska,
supra-footwear-tk-society, supra-footwear-ns-skytop, supra-footwear-suprano- deathwish and other styles. My favorite pair of golden perforation. I think my colleagues justin bieber shoes is also worth to try next. chenmiaomiao071016
From: air jordans for sale (hotadmiring@gmail.com / Monday, October 25, 2010 at 16:42:33)
This is a really quality post.I find this information through Google. Great job.cheap jordan shoe
From: jordan shoes for cheap (Jodie@hotmail.com / Monday, October 25, 2010 at 16:49:48)
You provide enriched information for us,thank u.new jordan shoes
From: designer handbags for cheap (eulogize13@live.com / Monday, October 25, 2010 at 16:53:28)
Good post.You did a good work,and offer more effective imformation for us!Thank you.coach handbags
From: designer clothes cheap (salespraise@msn.com / Monday, October 25, 2010 at 16:57:49)
I really like this website , and hope you will write more ,thanks a lot for your information.
fashion clothes
From: designer clothing wholesale (batter@hotmail.com / Monday, October 25, 2010 at 17:00:21)
This article is informative and interesting,I enjoy reading it.
clothes stores
From: cheap clothes online (dribble@aol.com / Monday, October 25, 2010 at 17:05:32)
These information helps me consider some useful things, keep up the good work.clothing for sale
From: ugg boots (1643435131@qq.com / Friday, October 29, 2010 at 10:52:51)
Form is no doubt a useful aspect that's considered whereas these shoes are bought. The two the Attractive Ballerinas and also the billig ugg Stiefel sandals preserve in thoughts the facet of product even though manufacturing and designing their numerous styles of footwear. These sneakers are in the marketplace in distinctive variety of model, UGG boots Sale, cardy ugg bootsunit too as shades like a end result of which they are ready to rapidly cater to your demands with all the pattern mindful prospects.cheap boots
boots on sale
The fees of either the Ugg sandals or maybe the very ballerinas aren¡¯t a great deal like a ugg boots australia
consequence of which it may perhaps probably even be bought by all individuals which includes a reduce funds. These model names specifically design shoes for females in order to meet the requirements with all the expanding fashion aware women.
ladies bootsaustralian ugg boots
So as to shop essentially the most recent assortment of Gorgeous Ballerinas as well as the ugg sandals on-line 1 certain can log on to panacheshoes.co.uk. This can be actually a reputed a reputable vendor and stocks numerous sorts of athletic shoes.cheap ugg boots The increased good quality trendy footwear are regularly cheap ugg bootscheapest ugg boots
out there beneath reductions. buy ugg boots Therefore this save may well be trusted to produce the put money into inside designer sneakers from entirely unique producers. cardy ugg bootstall ugg boots
It is a
sensational performance - without ever sentimentalizing the music,
he revels in the interpretative opportunities of the concerto.
Later, he would record it in a famous version with Efrem Kurtz, but
technically and interpretatively this beats that recording
hands-down. His playing is remarkably free of artifice and is
touched with an innocence that was a feature of Menuhin's
performances, but at a level which he would never again capture.
Landon Ronald was the in-house accompanist at that time (he also
conducted for many other soloists) and his treatment of the
orchestral parts is sympathetic and not at all obstrusive.
The
second disc is worth investing in as well -- Menuhin is here a few
years older and his accompanist is his teacher George(s) Enescu. His
performance of the Mendelssohn here already shows an understanding
of the Weltschmerz that he would explore in the later recordings of
the concerto, but again with an innocence of youth. He may be
technically more secure here than in the later recording, especially
with Furtwangler, but in both this and the Lalo, the conductor's
accompaniment is a tad too polite and deferential - not enough
characterization of the music and too self-effacing, too low key.
Still, one can enjoy Menuhin's treatment of the violin part, like a
soprano voice, singing always and with his agogic tempo adjustments
that made his interpretations special. Perhaps he felt restricted by
the presence of Enescu, yet from time to time his forceful
personality imposes itself. His performance of the second movement
is notable for the assured use of portamento and glissandi, and
sings like no other.
(Menuhin with Enescu, above)