current issue   writers' profiles    concert reviews   the inkvault 



RCA Living Stereo
(BMG Classics) 09026-626872
2 discs [114:29] mid-price
Full Libretto in English and Italian.
 


Giacomo Puccini

Turandot
 
Princess Turandot
Birgit Nilsson soprano

Calaf
Jussi Bjorling tenor

Liù
Renata Tebaldi, soprano

Timur Giorgio Tozzi tenor

Rome Opera Orchestra and Chorus
conducted by Erich Leinsdorf
 

Please help this site by visiting our sponsors!
 

by Ng Yeuk Fan

 
 


SceneRecently, a very good friend of mine was invited to watch the production of Turandot at the Forbidden City. The production was star-studded, directed by famed movie director of Raise the Red Lantern, Zhang Yimou. Tickets cost between US$150 and US$1500. Set to the colossal tapestry of the ancient palace, it was perhaps the most exciting operatic event of the year - even the decade. You can imagine my exasperation when my friend declined - on the grounds that he had to work.

Nevertheless, this review, dedicated to him, hopes that he will get a copy of this very good recording - and have a listen... before the actual copies of the Beijing production are available in Singapore.

Turandot, the title role, is the name of an icy princess who because of the tumultuous past of her ancestress, developed a Freudian fear of men who wish to win her love. With the reluctant agreement of her father, the Emperor, she announced publicly that whoever wishes to win her hand in marriage has to answer three riddles, failng which they will lose their head. Through this arrangement, many princes who had dared to make the bid had lost their lives in the gambit. It turns out that an unknown prince, Calaf, succeeds in answering her three riddles and in an act of generosity and love offers Turandot a chance to discover his name. If she succeeds by daybreak, he will willingly die. As it goes, the Princess orders that the entire country shall not sleep till the name of the prince is found; while the prince confidently muses on the words of the princess "None shall sleep" in the famous aria "Nessun dorma".

In a fateful turn of events, a servant girl Liu, who is in love with the Prince, is secretly caught and questioned by the Princess. Pronouncing her love for the Prince, she laments the paradox that should she reveal the Prince’s name, she would lose her love to the Princess by his death; on the other hand, should she keep quiet, she would lose her love to the Princess by their marriage. Caught in this difficult dilemma and tortured by the Princess’ men, she commits suicide to the surprise of the Princess, after expressing that her strength comes from Love.

Prince Calaf reproaches Turandot for her cruelty and then despite her horrified protests, he tears away her veil and kisses her forcibly. Shaken by the events and her resolution dissolving under the power of Calaf’s confidence, she admits that she had both loved and feared him since she first saw him. As dawn breaks, Prince Calaf reveals his name to the Princess and thus puts him in her power.

At dawn however, when Turandot and Calaf appears before the Emperor, she declares that the name of the stranger is Love.

PucciniPuccini did not complete this opera. It is said that at its first performance on April 25, 1926 (after the composer had been dead for almost a year and a half), Toscanini, who conducted, laid down the baton after the death of Liu in the third act and said: "The opera ends here, because at this point the Maestro died." On succeeding evenings however, he conducted the entire opera as we now know it, completed by Franco Alfano based on sketches made by the composer.

Interesting details that the sharp listener might pick out include the famous Chinese folk tune - "What a Beautiful Jasmine Flower" which Puccini merrily copied from the earliest imports of a few Chinese LPs he had chanced upon. It is said that a friend had arranged to have them delivered to his home as he had increasingly towards the end of his life become more interested in oriental themes and tunes from the Far East.

Critics believe that Turndot and Liu should ideally be lyrical and dramatic. Here in this chosen recording of Turandot, I am tempted to express that this ideal is achieved here in the balance of power between the usually dramatic Nilsson and the lyrical Tebaldi.

Birgit NilssonIn her delivery, Nilsson (right; of Wagner’s Ring's Brunnhilde fame) does not lack the required lyrical tone and in her thick dramatism, enhances the overall effectiveness of her already golden tone. She has no restraints soaring above the staves in her gruelling arias "In questa Reggia" and "Straniero, ascolta" In the latter aria , even Dame Joan Sutherland (Decca 414 274-2) is heard struggling to maintain her famed tone (a very rare thing indeed) at the highest of tessituras. Nilsson shows us what a true helden-soprano can do when borrowed over to ‘taxing’ Puccini heroines - and the effect is more than compelling; listen to ‘Figlio del Cielo!’.

Renata TelbadiTebaldi (left) on the other hand does not become overly sentimental and in her struggle of love-lost and imminent death, sings with plenty of noble dignity. Her testing aria "Tu che di gel sei cinta" may lack the certain dramatic poise of Callas or the floated pianissimi of Caballe made famous in "Signore, ascolta!" but Tebaldi's account remains one of the versions capable of withstanding the refiner’s fire - full of blue-veined nobility and her tone sufficiently thick to carry the required dramatic weight. Tebaldi without any question, was the prima donna assoluta of lyrical soprano roles.

Jussi Bjoerling Swedish tenor Jussi Bjoerling (right), now almost unheard of in the generation who has grown up with TVs and Pavarotti, is my choice of Calaf. Those accustomed to the dramatic version of "Nessun dorma" which has made Pavarotti famous should listen to Bjoerling’s more correct placement of this aria. In terms of sound and dramatic quality, Bjoerling does not overdo on both accounts - unlike Pavarotti, who has taken his signature song/role out of context - more fit for the World Cup than Turandot. Throughout, known for his beautiful sweet tenor voice, Bjoerling displays a warm heroic sound, secure in all registers, even and solid minus the harsh brightness of our other famed tenor while imbued with plenty of style and subtle nuance. No heroism should be lacking here, no need to overstate it either. Bjoerling is heard here in his prime.

The playing of the Rome Opera Orchestra under Leinsdorf sounds thin and understated. Understandably, the 1960s recording did not have the advantage of digital treatment. However, accompanying the glorious sound of the singers, all captured without any loss, Leinsdorf conjures a very refined sound from the string section, shimmering with excitment when required and somehow aptly bright, befitting the oriental theme, the oriental melodies and the subject matter. The brass is employed to great effect with superb control. Otherwise, small problems in ensemble-playing may be detected here and there; however, they do not mar my overall enjoyment of the performances. The chorus is effective in their interplay with Ping, Pong and Pang; the three ministers of Turandot.

The famed Living Stereo sound and the merits of this recording - from the legendary Nilsson, the remarkable Leinsdorf and the understated Tebaldi and Bjoerling - all point to a sure buy at mid-price.

Ng Yeuk Fan wishes someone would ask him to a date at the opera.


 
Our Awards Write for us! Writers' Profiles Martha Argerich Random Review
All original texts are copyrighted. Please seek permission from the Classical Editor
if you wish to reproduce/quote Inkpot material.







 
 

More Inkpot!

 

 

Inktroductions!

 

  Buying CDs
 


In Singapore, classical music CDs may be bought most inexpensively from SING MUSIC, The number to call is (+65) 6235 8960. The address is 304 Orchard Road #02-75 Lucky Plaza Singapore 238863. Simply mention the magic words "The Flying Inkpot" and receive 10% off all purchases (except for nett items). Make a trip down, you won't regret it!

Some great online sites are :

ArchiveMusic.com :
www.archivmusic.com

Berkshire Record Outlet :
www.broinc.com

Amazon.com:
www.amazon.com www.amazon.ca

MDT : http://www.mdt.co.uk


Crotchet Web Store (UK) www.crotchet.co.uk
Zweitausendeins:
www.zweitausendeins.de


Happy buying! The Flying Inkpot has NO affiliations with any music labels or music stores.

 


  Links to check out
 


Unnatural Acts of Opera - by La Cieca - Don't be put off by the strange name - this self-acclaimed queer operazine, presented by the deliciously camp (but knowledgeable) La Cieca, comes up regularly with historical performances which you can (with the aid of Apple's iTunes music player) download and listen to (you have to subscribe to Unnatural Acts, but it's free). Alternatively you can listen live on the website. Among recent podcasts are a live 1969 La Boheme with Pavarotti and Freni, a live Martha Modl/Ramon Vinay Tristan and much more. "La Cieca" provides her spicy commentary with every episode.