|
First, to settle
the controversy over the release of this disc, this is NOT a new
recording but an extraordinarily worthwhile one nonetheless. Piotr
Anderszewski originally made this recording, his first, for Polish
Accord in 1996, six years after he had walked out of the Leeds Piano
Competition. That event was a controversy in itself. He had played
Beethoven’s Diabelli Variations brilliantly and was halfway through
the Webern Variations when he suddenly stopped playing and walked
out of the hall.
As Anderszewski
himself phrased it the liner notes,
"Agents threw
themselves on me and the press got up a campaign on my behalf.
They should have suspected that I was someone with problems and
left me alone."
In some ways this
disc can be taken not only as superlative music making but also as
Anderszewski’s exorcism of inner demons from the trauma of the Leeds
experience. That would make it no coincidence that the heart of
this recording is Beethoven’s Op 110 sonata, a piece that was for
its composer a similar probing and overcoming of psychic and
spiritual turmoil on a deep and highly personal level.
As he showed in
his recording of the Diabelli Variations (read
the review here), Anderszewski can
not only get under the composer’s skin but also delve into his
psyche with a maturity and insight far beyond his years. Leonard
Bernstein used to say that whenever he was on the podium, he
conducted with the ideal of becoming the composer whose music he was
performing. Anderszewski does exactly this with Op 110. He plays
it as though he is Beethoven, experiencing the music first-hand and
improvising as he is going along instead of performing something
written down for almost 200 years. It is maybe no surprise then, as
the liner notes state, that Anserszewski would eventually like to
conduct the Missa Solemnis, the piece with which Beethoven felt the
closest bond and through which he bared his soul as he did in no
other work.
When he wrote Opp
109, 110 and 111 in 1820, Beethoven (right) was in the midst of a deep
spiritual crisis, something he had been working out in his personal
faith compositionally through the Missa. Those last three sonatas
are really emotional and spiritual snapshots of what was churning
within himself. While we do not have without Beethoven himself to
interview about what he was feeling while he was composing these
works or the Missa, consider the timeline involved. Beethoven had
finished the Kyrie and Gloria of the Missa and interrupted work on
the Credo to compose Opp 109-111. The text of the Credo is
basically Romans 10:9-10, which is not only a touchstone of
Christianity in general but a direct and highly personal cornerstone
of faith:
I believe in
one God, the Father almighty
Maker of heaven and earth
And of
all things visible and invisible.
(And) in one Lord Jesus Christ,
the only-begotten Son of God
Born of the Father before all ages:
God of God, light of light, true God of true God;
begotten not
made; consubstantial with the Father;
by Whom all things were
made.
Who for us men, and for our salvation,
came from heaven;
and was incarnate by the Holy Ghost, of the Virgin Mary; and was
made man.
He was crucified also for us, suffered under Pontius
Pilate, and was buried.
And on the third day He rose again
according to the Scriptures; and ascended into heaven.
He sitteth
at the right hand of the Father; and He shall come again with
glory to judge the living and the dead; and His Kingdom shall have
no end.
I believe in the Holy Ghost,
the Lord and giver of life,
who proceedeth from the Father and the Son,
Who together with the
Father and the Son is adored and glorified; Who spoke by the
Prophets.
I believe in one holy Catholic and apostolic Church.
I
confess one baptism for the remission of sins. And I await the
resurrection of the dead, and the life of the world to come.
Amen.
According to the liner notes for the
Levine/Salzburg recording of the Missa (and mentioned in other
sources) Beethoven's faith was a highly personal but conflicted one,
with Christianity, the philosophy of the Enlightenment and Eastern
religious philosophy colliding in his mind and spirit. He wrote of
God as "my refuge, my rock" in his personal diary of 1812-18 while
also quoting passages from Eastern sources. Beethoven was a
contradiction in other ways as well. He was a purported lover of
humanity who acted like a self-absorbed misanthrope. He was given
to rages over the most minor of human foibles yet could look on
those tirades with humorous detachment. (Is it any surprise that
one of his wittiest compositions is titled “Rage Over a Lost Penny,
Stormed Out in a Caprice”?) An alcoholic father mentally and
physically abused Beethoven as a child yet, in the pattern of many
who are abused, the composer became an oppressive and overly
protective guardian to his nephew Karl. He was petty, childish,
unforgiving, a continual whiner about his circumstances and not the
most honest businessman when it came to his compositions, yet he
wrote some of the loftiest music in human history. Plus Beethoven
was in continual torment over his deafness, which at this point had
become nearly total. Inner demons the man had in plenty.
It is interesting that Beethoven stopped work on the Missa just at
the point that, in terms of Romans 10:9-10, he would have to have
had to come to terms with himself in his heart and commit or perhaps
reaffirm himself to a personal relationship with his Lord and
Savior. It might have taken a lot of inner reflection, a dealing
with inner demons and a realization that he could not go on in the
way he had, that he had to surrender himself to the leading of an
inner power. Considering all the testimonies of people who have
claimed to have become Christians through various personal trials,
and considering how seriously and intensely Beethoven apparently
believed in the words he set to music in the Missa from the finished
product, the suggestion that he had such a similarly personal
revelation does not seem that outlandish. It is not that much
further a stretch to suggest that he would also express his personal
wrestling match with himself, his emotions and his faith in Op
109-111, perhaps not overtly but as a matter of course from
expressing himself directly and personally in his music as a whole.
In other words, we may not
have an interview with Beethoven to confirm all of this but there
are enough clues to make an educated case for it.
This seems to be exactly how Anderszewski
approaches Op 110 – with a sense of deep internal crisis and
introspection leading to revelation. Some complain that the first
movement as Beethoven wrote it sounds anemic and meandering, and
lacks the grandeur of Beethoven's other great sonatas. But it is
not meant to be a grand statement. It is a quiet and very lyrical
beginning much in the same vein as Op 101. Does the beginning of Op
101 meander? Or the begining of the Moonlight, for that matter?
Seems like Beethoven is beginning in what would be a familiar manner
for him in that movement. Part of Beethoven's genius was that he
could be so moving and communicate so much in the quieter moment of
his works as well as the "great" ones.
When the piece modulates into the minor key,
the sunniness of the opening is increasingly bathed in shadows, then
dusk. Even as Beethoven tries to continue smiling, the calm with
which he started is eroding fast. It is one of the subtlest yet
most pervasive and devastating moments in the composer’s output, as
complex as anything in the late Mozart piano concertos or the last
sonatas of Schubert, with several layers of emotions running
independent of and into one another all at the same time. The
character of this movement as it progresses is more than a rising
level of tragedy; it is a psychic unraveling the likes of which we
have never heard in Beethoven’s output before now. And as it
progresses, this music becomes an increasingly easy place to fall
into melodrama or to overplay with the fervor of the Hammerklavier
or Appassionata. Anderszewski understands the difference here. He
knows that this opening movement is infinitely more intricate and
multifaceted; instead of onward and forward, we are going inward,
becoming increasingly, almost obsessively ruminative. Time has
literally come to a standstill. Anderszewski plays this music
more like the Schubert B flat major sonata than what many of us are
used to – never really slow but lingering, tinged instead of steeped
with regrets and longings, with nothing overstated but every
sentiment laid bare and nothing resolved.
The arioso dolente that follows this
movement is no rustic dance or light interlude in Anderszewski’s
hands. It is a danse macabre, a whirling, vicious affair
with jabbing accents and no let-up until the final bars, when the
nightmare finally fades in the first moments of waking.
Anderszewski slows the pace and softens his tone in those final
measures – a highly effective transition as well as highlighting
musically the thought most of have had after an especially bad
dream: “Thank God it’s morning.”
The opening of the final movement moves on from “Thank God it’s
morning” to “Oh God, it’s morning” – the second thought that can
come when life look especially bad. The final movement is the
spiritual and emotional core of the work – Beethoven groping in the
dark until the light breaks in with a repeated chord leading to the
final fugue. That chord, played over and over a little louder each
time until the piano is practically shaking, has been called by some
one of the most absurd moments in all of classical music. It is
really Beethoven’s moment of epiphany, his personal breakthrough
leading to the uninhibited joy of the final measures. As in the
first movement, Anderszewski’s interpretation is phenomenal. He
traces the emotional and musical peaks and valleys with sensitivity,
conviction and immediacy both fresh and a little startling to hear.
For once the ending of this piece is not just another triumphant
conclusion but a moment of cleansing and catharsis, perhaps for
Anderszewski as well as for Beethoven.
How appropriate it is to have
Bach’s D minor English suite precede
the Beethoven as an opener. This is some of the most thoughtful,
penetrating Bach I have heard in a long time, with each line of
counterpoint given not only its own voice but individual
characteristics. The music becomes as much conversation as it does
musical exchange and interplay, never predictable but always
fresh-sounding, as though it, like the Beethoven, is being
improvised on the spot. It is occasionally very moving but never
overdone, from the wistful bittersweetness of the courante and
sarabande to the humorously tongue-in-cheek quality of the second
gavotte (which shows that yes, Bach did have a sense of humor after
all). Anderszewski gives the music ample time to breathe but never
drags or forces it into a hypermanic state, and treats it without
any starch of pomposity. Everything fits.
(above: J.S. Bach)
Above all, Anderszewswki never forgets that
these movements are dances. Accents are kept pointed, rhythms
lively and no matter what speed, to borrow Duke Ellington’s phrase,
everything swings. The wonderfully soulful way Anderszewski opens
the prelude – an introspective searching not far removed from the
Beethoven – gives way to highly animated and high-spirited play,
with Anderszewski reveling in the polyphony and melody while keeping
the music sprightly and light-footed. The rest of the suite is
treated just as nimbly. All this from someone who says Bach “was
not really my thing” when he recorded it.
The
Webern, on the other hand, was very much
Anderszewski’s thing, a hangover from Leeds that he plays here with
the searching intensity he brought to Bach and Beethoven plus a
volcanic, white-hot passion that takes the listener by the throat.
I’d never realized the connection between this work and the
Beethoven until hearing them side by side in this recording. Webern
and Beethoven both begin with a searching first movement, follow it
with a spiky, aggressive middle episode and progress to a third
movement that penetrates even more deeply into the human psyche,
continually questioning, answering, then questioning the answers.
In Webern, though, the final notes are both resolute and
inconclusive. It is a double-sided message that mirrors life itself
as a continual and perhaps in some ways never-ending quest.
above: Anton Webern
Overall this disc is everything it promises to be and a tremendous
amount more. The liner notes call Anderszewski’s Bach “an adventure
in sound,” but the performances as a whole are incisive and
insightful musical explorations of the soul and spirit as well. It
not only needs to be heard to be believed, but virtually demands it.
In Singapore, Virgin Classics may be bought most cheaply from Sing Music
at #02-75 Lucky Plaza . Call Doris for help at (+65)62358960. They
also take multiple orders and can supply Hyperion and many other
small labels. 10% discount if you mention The Flying Inkpot.
Readers' Comments
From: timberland 6 inch (boots@timberland6inch.com / Monday, July 12, 2010 at 17:30:21)
There were timberland 6 inch sensitivity and a beauty to her that have nothing to do with timberland 6 inch boots looks. She was one to be listened to, whose words were so easy to take to timberland boots sale heart.I used to find notes left in the collection basket, beautiful timberland boots outlet notes about my homilies and about the writer's black timberland boots thoughts on the daily scriptural readings. The person who penned the notes mens timberland boots would add reflections to my thoughts and would always include some timberland pro boots quotes from poets and mystics he or she had white timberland boots read and remembered and loved. The notes fascinated black timberland shoes uk me. Here was someone immersed in a search for truth and beauty. Words had been cheap timberland boots treasured, words that were beautiful. And I felt as if the words timberland waterproof boots somehow delighted in being discovered, for they were obviously very generous to the as yet anonymous timberland work boots writer of the notes. And now this person was in turn learning the secret of sharing them. Beauty so shines when given away. The only truth that exists timberland hiking boots is, in that sense, free.
From: replica handbags (mdo@gmail.com / Thursday, July 29, 2010 at 09:23:10)
chanel
gucci
hermes
louis vuitton
designer handbags
vertu phones
designer handbags reviews
replica handbags
replica phones
vertu replica
tag heuer phone
mobiado
cartier-phones
goldvish
rolex mobile
porsche phone
replica blackberry
iphone replica
From: shely (hxj@126.com / Tuesday, August 3, 2010 at 15:52:17)
It's a interesting news,i like it.Additionally,wellcome to my website oboots.There are so many cheap ugg boots such as:
ugg ukuggs on salecheap ugg bootsugg classic boots
ugg bailey button|ugg bailey button boots|ugg argyle knit|ugg argyle knit boots|ugg cardy|ugg classic cardy boots|ugg crochet|ugg crochet boots|ugg flower|ugg flower boots|ugg leopard|ugg leopard boots|UGG Classic Tall Leopard|UGG Classic Tall Leopard boots|ugg mini|ugg classic mini boots|ugg paisley|ugg paisley boots|UGG Classic Short Paisley|UGG Classic Short Paisley boots|UGG Short Paisley|UGG Short Paisley boots|ugg short|ugg classic short boots|ugg tall|ugg classic tall boots|ugg elsey wedge|ugg elsey wedge boots|ugg infants erin|ugg infants erin boots|ugg langley|ugg langley boots|ugg lo pro|ugg lo pro boots|ugg locarno|ugg locarno boots|ugg mayfaire|ugg mayfaire boots|ugg nightfall|ugg nightfall boots|ugg rainier eskimo|ugg rainier eskimo boots|UGG Sundance II|UGG Sundance II boots|ugg ultimate bind|ugg ultimate bind boots|ugg ultra short|ugg ultra short boots|ugg ultra tall|ugg ultra tall boots|ugg suede|ugg suede boots|ugg upside|ugg upside boots|ugg roxy|ugg roxy boots|ugg seline|ugg seline boots|ugg corinth wedge|ugg corinth wedge boots|ugg liberty|ugg liberty boots|ugg highkoo|ugg highkoo boots|ugg knightsbridge|ugg knightsbridge boots|ugg bomber jacket|ugg bomber jacket boots|ugg adirondack|ugg adirondack boots|ugg suburb crochet|ugg suburb crochet boots|UGG Roseberry Suede|UGG Roseberry Suede Boots|UGG Smithfield Tall|UGG Smithfield Tall Boots|UGG Gaviota|UGG Gaviota Boots|UGG Brookfield Tall|UGG Brookfield Tall Boots|UGG Ashur|UGG Ashur Boots|UGG Cove|UGG Cove Boots|UGG Desoto|UGG Desoto Boots|UGG Shoreline|UGG Shoreline Boots|UGG Tess|UGG Tess Boots|UGG High Heel Tall|UGG High Heel Tall Boots|UGG Caroline|UGG Caroline Boots|UGG Stella|UGG Stella Boots|UGG Swell Tall|UGG Swell Tall Boots|UGG Men's Brookfield|UGG Men's Brookfield Boots|
ugg boots|uggs on sale|cheap ugg boots|ugg size guide|
There are so much style of cheap ugg boots,so once you go to my website you will be very surprise.
From: ascscascasc (ascsadvdsf@wsdsa.com / Tuesday, August 17, 2010 at 10:05:01)
Wholesale Clothing China
Korean Fashion
Korean Wholesale Clothing
Wholesale Clothing Distributors
Korean Clothes Wholesale
Korean Fashion Wholesale
Wholesale Korean Clothes
China Clothing Wholesale
Korea Wholesale
Korean Dress
China Fashion Wholesale
Wholesale China Clothing
Korean Clothing Wholesale
Wholesale Korean Fashion
Chinese Wholesale Clothes
From: UGG Boots Shoes Sale (uggbootsshoes@163.com / Wednesday, September 29, 2010 at 13:24:15)
Useful information,Thank you for sharing.Also Hope you to buy ugg,boots shoes,ugg boots,buy ugg boots,argyle knit,knit argyle,mini boots,buy leather boots,boots on sale,boots sale,2010 ugg boots,ugg boots 2010,boots store,classic crochet,classic crochet boots,womens boots on sale,boots for sale,boots in sale,short boots,classic boots,ugg australia,classic tall,discount ugg boots,ugg 2010,ugg company,ugg discount boots,ugg bailey button,cheap womens boots,discount womens boots,womens boots,cheap leather boots,discount leather boots,leather boots,ugg australia boots,uggstore,kids snow boots,snow boots for kids,uggs 2010,uggs,ugg boots discount,cheap ugg boots,classic knit,ugg 5879,classic argyle knit,classic argyle knit boots,ugg classic argyle knit,classic mini boot,classic sheepskin,classic mini,cheap winter boots,discount winter boots,classic mini for sale,buy classic mini,classic sheepskins,comfortable boots,short leather boots,best winter boots,knee high boots,boat shoes,blue boots,boots online,womens boot,furry boots for women,cheap tall boots,girls boots,thigh boots,thigh high boots,fur boots cheap,waterproof boots, thigh high boots for women, cheap furry boots,full fur boots,ugg classic crochet 5833,ugg 5833 boots,crochet boot,fur boots on sale,cheap crochet boots,crochet boots,ugg 5833,boots uk,green ankle boots,where to buy boots,classic crochet tall,
cheap fashion boots,cheap flat boots,flat boots,classic boot,over the knee boots,short boot,boots on line,black leather boots,ugg 5825 boots,short sand,high leather boots,pink in boots,knee boots,ugg classic short 5825,ugg 5825,short classics,classic short 5825,boots usa,australia classic short boots,
winter boots,winter boots for women on sale,winter boots on sale,boot shop,knitted boots for women,classic cardy 5819,australia classic cardy boots,australia classic cardy,classic cardy black,australia cardy classic boot,ugg 5819,ugg 5819 boots,ugg classic cardy 5819,grey cardy boots,cream boots,white boots,black cardy boots,classic tall sand,red back boots,red boots,ugg 5815 boots,pink boots for women,ugg classic tall 5815,classic tall 5815,
leggings and boots,ugg 5815,waterproof leather boots,waterproof sheepskin boots,classic tall metallic,cheap fur boots,waterproof winter boots,golden boot,gold boots,gold ankle boots,bailey button boot,pink fur boots,snow boot,bailey button 5803,bailey button chocolate,ugg bailey button 5803,ugg 5803,black knit boots,shop for boots,woman boots on sale,womens shoes boots,boots shop,classic sheepskin boots,boots to buy,buy boots,fur boots for women,green boots,boots with fur,female boots,real fur boots,cheap snow boots,ugg 5359,furry boot,cheap grey boots,cheap brown boots,cozy boots,woman boots,long black boots,black shoe boots,big boots,boot for women,cheap over the knee boots,boot on sale,lace up boots,boot for sale,ankle boots,cheap thigh high boots,cheap knee high boots,boots that are in style,style boots,tall sheepskin boot,boots and all,tall boots,tall boots on sale,snow wear,fall boots,boots shoe stores,patent boots,patent leather boots,love from australia,boot uk,hot boots,shoes australia,kid classic,new boots,boots with the fur,
grey boots for women,grey boots on sale,boots on sales,boots sales,boots and more,womens boots and shoes,long boots,button boot,pink boots,leather boots on sale,long leather boots,cheap ankle boots,grey boot,grey boots,boot chocolate,black boots,fashion boots,fur boots.How do you think? Follow with me,Never Regret!
From: Yahoo (nba.333@163.com / Thursday, December 30, 2010 at 17:10:04)
Belstaff is well known for belstaff jackets, belstaff shoes and belstaff bags, which are highly praised by consumers in European market. This short paragraph is mainly talking about the belstaff bags. One is belstaff travel bag, which is a hard-wearing item with an army-like edge and constructed from the dark khaki material and usually trimmed with brown raw leather. Among the collections of belstaff travel bags, there are three types, which are respectively belstaff travel 561 mountain brown bag, belstaff colonial travel bag and belstaff purple leather travel bag. In details, Belstaff travel 561 mountain brown bag has two press stud fastening front pockets with additional leather straps, two carry handles and detachable shoulder straps; Belstaff colonial travel bag is made of English cotton canvas, which is available in mountain and sells for $69; belstaff purple leather travel bag is suitable for men and women, which features a leather finish, main zipper opening, two leather carry handles straps and has two front pockets with press stud fastenings. Another is belstaff leather bag, which is a rectangular shaped messenger with front snap pocket and adjustable leather strap. If you want to learn more, you can have a profound understanding from the belstaff official website. .(wang yu). .12.30
From: cheap beats by dre (shiristian@qq.com / Friday, July 15, 2011 at 14:05:28)
goad them into killing him by pointing a pellet gun gun cheap Beats By Dre Studio gun at the officers.Everything that we know, we would be
to use that term suicide-by-cop, Lt. Troy D. Little, with with hot pink dre beats with the New York State Police, told ABC News.Justin Arnold,
of Cazenovia, N.Y., had no criminal history. Police are investigating investigating Power Beats By Dre investigating his mental state or any mental health issues that
From: Ugg boots australia (shiristian@qq.com / Friday, July 15, 2011 at 15:49:50)
to inspire all women.President Obama said in a statement that that uggs boots store that Ferraro will forever be remembered as a trailblazer who
down barriers for women, and Americans of all backgrounds and and and walks of life. Whether it was as a public
teacher, assistant district attorney, Member of Congress, or candidate for for for Vice President, Geraldine fought to uphold America's founding ideals
From: who cares (hhuang06@gmail.com / Thursday, July 21, 2011 at 08:31:18)
It's a interesting news.Free shipping and discount puma shoes online sale now,get the cheapest puma shoes in http://www.pumahi.org/.there are so many style of puma shoes here.such as Mens Puma Basket Shoes|Mens Puma Baylee Future Cat|Mens Puma BMW Sauber F1|Mens Puma Brazil Edition|Mens Puma Doshu Combat|Mens Puma Drift Cat Shoes|Mens Puma Ferrari Shoes|Mens Puma Future Cat shoes|Mens Puma Grit Cat III Shoes|Mens Puma Speed Cat Shoes|Puma Running Shoes|Women's Puma Baylee Future|Women's Puma Drift Cat II|Women's Puma Engine Cat Low|Women's Puma Espera shoes|Women's Puma Ferrari Shoes|Women's Puma Fluxion II|Women's Puma Fur Shoes|Women's Puma Future Cat|Women's Puma Grit Cat III.I believe you could find the shoes you like best from thise websites.
From: ¥é¥ë¥Õ¥í©`¥ì¥ó (polo0000@gmail.com / Friday, March 30, 2012 at 10:31:58)
¥é¥ë¥Õ¥í©`¥ì¥ó¤Þ¤¿¡¢¥É¥¤¥Ä¼ˆ¤Ç¥Ë¥å¥ë¥ó¥Ù¥ë¥¯¤Ø¤ÎÒÆ¼®¤¬ˆó¤¸¤é¤ì¤Æ¤¤¤¿¥Ð¥¤¥¨¥ë¥ó¥Ý¥í¥é¥ë¥Õ¥í©`¥ì¥ó¤Î£Í£ÆÓî×ôÃÀ¤Ï£²£¸ÈÕ¡¢¡¸½ñ¤Î¤È¤³¤í£¨ˆóµÀ¤Î£©ÄÚÈݤÏégß`¤Ã¤Æ¤¤¤Ê¤¤¡£Ç°Ïò¤¤Ë¿¼¤¨¤Æ¤¤¤ë¡¹¤ÈÕJ¤á¤¿¡£
From: jkyk (284185130@qq.com / Thursday, April 19, 2012 at 14:46:27)
his fault." 9 Things That Make Allergies WorseSurprising Reasons Your Symptoms are Acting UpBy the the the editors of PreventionMay 28, 2011 If you're a seasonal allergy sufferer (60 million of
are), you probably already have a few tricks to avoid triggers, like not running outside outside outside when pollen counts are sky-high or keeping the windows closed and blasting the AC.
you may not know about these less obvious factors that can make symptoms worse.Stressful work work air jordan chaussure work deadlinesIn a 2008 experiment, researchers at Ohio State University College of Medicine found that
From: fgdhgdh (zonglin823@hotmail.com / Tuesday, April 24, 2012 at 15:01:09)
just want Caylee back, that's all they're worried about right now," Casey Anthony says on on Coach Purses on the call.Casey Anthony reprimands her mother on the call for telling the media that
didn't know what her daughter's involvement in Caylee's disappearance was."You're blaming me that you're sitting sitting Cheap coach purses for sale sitting in the jail? Blame yourself for telling lies," Cindy Anthony told her daughter in
call.Casey Anthony's attorney Jose Baez led Cindy Anthony through a series of questions about her her her daughter's friends, lovers and co-workers, complete with details of them getting haircuts, working on
All
original texts are copyrighted. Please seek permission from the
Classical Editor
if you wish to reproduce/quote Inkpot material.
|