imagemap


Open Rehearsal & Concert
Friday
12 March 1999

Victoria Concert Hall
GALA CONCERT
Yo-Yo Ma in Concert
Claude DEBUSSY Ibéria from Images, op.21
Bright SHENG (b.1955) Two Poems for Violoncello and Orchestra
Edward ELGAR Cello Concerto in E minor, Op.85

Yo-Yo MA cello
SHUI Lan conductor

OVERALL NOISE RATING: 1 (The usual coughs and beeps, but generally, a very attentive audience.)

The Noise Rating Index is a partially-objective measurement of pager and handphone blasts, 9pm and 10pm watch beeps, coughing-during-the-pianissimo-bits, intra-audience conversation and other mind-bogglingly inept noises emitted in the concert hall during actual performance of music. It is measured on a scale of 0 to 5, in increasing annoyance.

This review has been kindly sponsored in part by the Singapore Symphonia Co. Ltd.


by Chia Han-Leon and Johann D'Souza

Johann D'Souza's Friday morning:

Sir Edward Elgar
ON FRIDAY morning, about 450-500 people gathered inside the Victoria Concert Hall to watch the open rehearsal for these concerts. Some came as early as 7.30am. This event is quite unprecedented in all the years that I have gone to the SSO. Yo-Yo Ma came in at about 9.45 am after the orchestra went through Debussy's Ibéria. Most of the time was spent rehearsing Bright Sheng's Two Poems, and it was only after the break at 11.25am that Yo-Yo Ma came back for the Elgar concerto.

Having heard Yo-Yo Ma play twice before (the solo recital in 1995, and the awesome 1997 performances of two pinnacles of the cello repertoire - the Shostakovich First Cello Concerto and the darling of all cello concertos, the Dvorak), I can declare that hearing Yo-Yo Ma perform is always a mystical experience. To hear him play the Elgar concerto only confirms his stature as a premier world-class performer, and likely the world's greatest in the 21st century.

A consummate performer, Yo-Yo Ma possesses characteristics difficult to put into words. I have now heard him 'live' in three different concertos from composers of different nationalities and after reviewing his Sony recording of Tavener's The Protecting Veil, I am further in awe at the fact that not only does he play all extremely well, but he makes the concertos look as if they were all written for him. His understanding of the music extends beyond the depths of all previous interpretations; and while you know that he could not have had an opportunity to speak to, say Elgar, his treatment of every score is filled with enlightening thought. You are immediately drawn to the freshness of his readings, and yet they inevitably sound as if he has played them all his life.

Yo-Yo Ma The introduction of the Elgar concerto was filled with heightened melancholia and straightaway the pain and suffering emotion associated with the work comes through. I have heard so many recordings of this concerto, but with Yo-Yo Ma, the introduction delivers its impact immediately to the listener. Everything comes to him intuitively, without any sense of dogmatic playing. Using long bow strokes as a pivot, he brings out the pathos with great urgency. I somehow felt united with him as if he played this concerto only for me. Yo-Yo Ma's performance extended beyond the audience to something I can only describe as ethereal, and yet it reached down to the individual seated in the concert hall.

Mr Ma never took on the concerto alone as one could see by the visual connection between him and the principal players of all the string sections. Shui Lan was also ever-vigilant to his needs and you could not but help notice that the Orchestra was performing with a greater sense of enthusiasm. I recently came across this quotation: "The performer's role is to inspire the audience to follow him in his devotion, his devotional act." You cannot but believe that Yo-Yo Ma has taken Singaporeans attending his concerts on this journey, a journey within oneself to a higher plane.

Technically Yo Yo is faultless, every facet of his playing is visually impacting . From the beginning all the way to the end you can see that sense of ‘struggle’ in his playing, a struggle not at the notes but a struggle for perfection according to how he sees it. I suppose that is how every minute detail is skillfully crafted, from extended phrases to longer and deeper bow strokes in the lower registers, his glissandi and harmonics were clear as crystal and made to look easy. I am happy to say that the Montagnana cello truly belongs in his hands, a gift from heaven. His cadenza in the third movement and the recapitulation of the opening theme literally brought me to tears and I was not at all astonished that this impact was felt by so many people at the concert.

Yo-Yo Ma's humility and generosity was seen at the end when he tried to get the audience to cheer for the orchestra rather than for him, as if he only had a minor role to play. For an encore, he played for us the Allemande from Bach's Sixth Cello Suite. Being the renowned "Mr. Nice Guy of classical music", he must have signed at least 400 autographs at the open rehearsal and took dozens of photos with his adoring fans. Lucky indeed, ironically, were the people who could not get tickets for the actual concerts but managed to sit in for the rehearsal. Last Friday, I went home a very happy man, happy not only to have been in the presence of a great performer but a true ambassador of music to the world, someone I know who will continue to have further impact on music in the coming years.


As recounted by Chia Han-Leon:

Bright Sheng
ONE THING that has struck and pleased me is that both Yo-Yo Ma and Bright Sheng (both born in 1955, incidently) pay considerable attention to the idea of music as image. During the masterclass (guess you didn't know about this), a lucky friend of mine who attended said that Mr Ma was not one to pick on the (even luckier) cellists' technique, where not necessary. Instead, I was told that he would encourage the musicians to create an image of the music being played, and let that image evoke the music.

Before the Two Poems were played, Bright Sheng (Chinese name: SHENG Zong-Liang; photo right) came up on stage, after a brief intro by Shui Lan, to speak about the piece. Right from the start, his focus again was on the music as image. Combine this with the basic literary source of the music, and you can imagine the potential evocative power of the experience.

The first poem, "Midnight Bells", is inspired by a Tang dynasty poem. It begins, as the title suggets, as if we were a scene in deep night. The detached invocation of bells and wood blocks, spaced apart with silence, immediately brought to my mind the familiar image of the Chinese nightwatch, who would walk around town with gong and wood block, announcing the hour and ensuring the peace. In those days, there was no public lighting, hence the image which this music evokes is even more vividly dark. The lonely cello song, featuring Yo-Yo Ma's richly clear harmonic playing, pierces the darkness.

Bright Sheng's clear orchestration wins my complete admiration. More than that, his capacity to distill the essence of every gesture from the score makes the music seem like the sonic expression of a Chinese painting, complete with its miniature figures, pavilions and huts. Although there is some degree of noise (which the composer admits to), I found the piece generally serene - like a Chinese landscape painting full of subtle light movements, constantly avoiding the sense of weight. There is a passage, if I remember correctly, where a glissed phrase on cello is embellished lightly by harps, over a woodwind pedal trill with additional short bird-like motifs emitted from the background - beautiful.

Every gesture from the cello solo, each rapt invocation of wisps of tune makes complete intelligible sense in the overall poem. Not surprisingly, many stylistics of Chinese instrumental technique are employed, such as turned glissandi and the curving of phrase-ends. But nowhere have I heard it as effectively employed as it is here. I mean this both in terms of the composer's writing and Yo-Yo Ma's playing. In addition, the hard pizzicato, abrupt and with expressive silences between each note, powerfully evokes the rhythm and style of Chinese poetry recital. Made to pizzicato in the lower ranges, as well as harmonics, this imitated the guqin, an unfretted 7-string zither with a history of over 2000 years, greatly revered in Chinese literati. The monosyllabic language is in turn echoed beautifully by the two harps, scored and tuned to sound like the guzheng. (More from Derek below)

During the concert on Friday, the truth be told, much of the detail described above was obscured to some extent, compared to the open rehearsal in the morning. During the latter, Bright Sheng was very particular over dynamic balance, often running up on stage to shush accompanying instruments and secondary lines. In fact, he explained to the orchestra that parts of the score demanded that different sections played loud and soft at the same time. During the concert itself, there were a few points where Yo-Yo Ma was actually drowned by the overenthusiastic wind section. Unfortunately, we only got to hear the Poems in fragmented (rehearsal) form in the morning.

The second Poem, "Spring Opera", derives some of its material from the famous Beijing Opera, Farewell to My Concubine. But as Bright Sheng explained to the audience, much of the recognisable tunes have been "elaborated"/fragmented beyond recognition, with perhaps just brief hints left. This must have also happened in his China Dreams which the SSO performed in 1997; then it did not impress me. I confess now that it was probably my failure to appreciate his elaboratory process. I can no longer remember how China Dreams sounds like, but without a doubt I am much much more impressed with the Two Poems.

"Spring Opera" begins with a stroke on the tam-tam, but eventually becomes much "noisier" than the first Poem. The transparent orchestration nevertheless remains breathtaking. The balance of horizontal and vertical writing seems to reflect Bright Sheng's effective synthesis of Beijing Opera stylistics and Western orchestral resources. The theatrical gestures translate both in terms of colour, which is very focussed, and in visual terms, where the pinpoint orchestration allows one to see every action. There is a two-note cell in the work which appears many times; say, in that catchy and insistent string motif towards the end, the operatic "words" for the cello and the double-chord crash which contrasts with each quiet phrase. After an intense passage filled with Shostakovichian sardonic wit, the piece ends quietly in suspension. Yo-Yo Ma played the piece with a sense of ease and familiarity. Attacking his solos with gusto and glee, he infused the work with an infectious enthusiasm which I found completely palpable.  

WITH REGARD to the performances of the Elgar Cello Concerto, one thing is unanimously agreed among the three writers writing this review. First let me say that we three managed to attend both the concert performance and the open rehearsal on Friday. Derek, the ever intrepid one, even got to see the Saturday performance. The conclusion among us will probably surprise some, especially those of you who went all out to get the precious concert tickets: of the three performances - without doubt - the best, most moving one was the run-through during the open rehearsal. Followed by the Saturday performance (on Derek's word), and least (but still) impressive, Friday's.

You could feel the tremendous effect on the audience after the open rehearsal. Reports of people crying trickled into my ears as I waited the nine hours separating the rehearsal and the evening performance. Yo-Yo Ma does not just play for himself or the composer, he plays for the audience and the orchestra. Indeed, it is plainly obvious that he plays with the orchestra. Dressed in black polo shirt and jeans, Mr Ma would lean towards and watch the section or players as they accompanied him. Even from row L where we were seated (the best seats for this open rehearsal), you could see the deeply sincere expression on his face. Responding tenderly or heartburstingly, the SSO drew their best, most focussed and balanced sound for him.

Yo-Yo Ma What won my admiration straightaway was how he did not overindulge in the overt Romantic aspects of the music, yet managed to make it sound incredibly noble and supremely anguished. For a moment in time, all of humanity's emotions seemed to pass through this great man and his magnificent instrument. As he sat there with his cello, half-shrouded in shadow, I thought the sky opened and angels of music peered down into the hall, weeping at the torrent of ecstatic anguish Mr Ma drew from himself and the concerto. It was an incredible experience. I now begin to understand what the name "Yo-Yo Ma" means. This man is beyond greatness; he is the human incarnation of the cello.

Alas (and perhaps it is due to our over-expectation), this intensity was not reached during Friday evening's concert performance. Somehow, everything was much milder and the feeling was more formal; all the performers lacked the degree of care and feeling reached during the rehearsal. Nevertheless, it remained a moving experience for many.

I have just one last experience to recount: immediately after the open rehearsal, ever the obliging one, Yo-Yo Ma came out to meet the line of 300+ people gathered to get his autograph. When it was my turn, I could see that he was very tired, his face red with exhaustion. Yet it seemed only the exhaustion of the body - such must have been the power he summoned for the Elgar - but his spirit never seems to tire. Weary or not, Mr Ma had nothing but smiles and handshakes for everyone. When a girl before me started to ask questions, even his polite decline ("...there are others waiting in line..."), always with a smile, was filled with genuine human warmth.

As he was signing my programme booklet, I said to him, "Thank you, Mr Ma: I understand so much more now." His immediate response was one of innocent and surprised delight: "You did?? Really? That's great! That's what open rehearsals are for!" And then before I could even react, he offered me his hand to shake!

Mr Ma, you have no idea how much you have made me understand.

Chia Han-Leon and Johann D'Souza offer their sincere apologies to Monsieur Debussy.

Click to Return to the Concert Index!...
or Visit the Inkvault archives!

427: 14.3.1999 ©Chia Han-Leon, Johann D'Souza

Explore the Flying Inkpot

They're Alive!
Concert Reviews

Bit deadish:

Other Resources at The Flying Inkpot
Home
MORE STUFF
  • Another review of the concert(s)...

  • ReSSOnance III The Unofficial ReSSOnance Forum

  • Singapore Symphony Orchestra Homepage

  • SISTIC

    Do you have a website relating to classical music performance in Singapore? Tell us about it! Email classical@inkpot.com